WEST CHESTER, Ohio — Eight women and eight men from Butler County will decide if Gurpreet Singh is guilty of capital murder.
Prosecutors and defense attorneys spent two days vetting jury candidates. Tuesday evening, they picked a 12-person jury with four alternates.
The trial, which could last three weeks, began Wednesday with jurors getting a tour of the Wyndtree apartment where the victims died. Testimony starts Thursday.
Butler County prosecutors accuse Singh, 40, of killing his wife Shalinderjit Kaur, 39; his in-laws Hakikat Singh Pannag, 59, and Parmjit Kaur, 62; and his aunt by marriage, Amarjit Kaur, 58, at an apartment on Wyndtree Drive in West Chester on April 28, 2019. If convicted, Singh could get the death penalty.
He pleaded not guilty to all charges and is represented by Charlie Rittgers.
The trial is the first to be held in Butler County's "super courtroom," according to Judge Greg Howard who will hear the case. The space used to be two separate rooms before renovations turned into the largest trial space in the courthouse.
Monday, the court summoned 91 potential jurors. 81 showed up. Of that number, Judge Howard excused 43. Neither prosecutors nor Singh's attorneys objected.
Before screening potential jurors, the judge heard motions by prosecutors to introduce evidence the defense called "hearsay."
Prosecutors claim Singh had an affair and want the alleged mistress to testify. They also requested bank documents be admitted as proof of motive. Howard accepted the motions.
However, Howard tabled admission of evidence regarding a financial dispute prosecutors claim Singh had with his father-in-law. Prosecutors said Singh demanded interest and proceeds from the sale of land Hakikat Singh Pannag owned in India. They claim Singh assaulted Pannag prior to the murders and lied to investigators about how well the two men got along.
Singh's attorney objected and called the evidence hearsay. Judge Howard planned to hear other motions after jury selection.
Author and freelance journalist Sonia Chopra interviewed Singh in a Sikh gurdwara days after the murders. She said the case is important to the community.
"For the Sikh, they believe that justice must be done," she said. "They are quiet people but proud and the killing of old people and the killing of a woman at the prime of her life with three small children has hurt them deeply and they're very angry. They want justice to be done. On the other hand, they are also aware the (Singh) kids will (potentially) be orphaned depending on how it works it out."
Chopra interviewed Singh's parents in India Friday. They do not believe money, real estate or an affair were motives.
READ MORE
3 years after West Chester family killed, murder trial set for Oct. 3
Jury selection begins in trial for man accused of killing wife, 3 other family members in West Chester
Judge: Man accused of killing 4 relatives in West Chester can use public funds for defense experts
